inner-banner-bg

Environmental Science and Climate Research(ESCR)

ISSN: 2996-2498 | DOI: 10.33140/ESCR

Instrument Mix in Climate Change Law Legal Design, Regulatory Interaction and the Architecture of Decarbonisation

Abstract

Panagiotis Galanis

Climate change law is no longer organised around the choice of a single optimal regulatory instrument. Contemporary legal orders combine emissions trading, carbon taxation, performance standards, renewable-energy obligations, energy- efficiency duties, planning rules, subsidy regimes, disclosure requirements, border measures, public investment and social compensation. This study examines that combination as an instrument mix: a legally structured set of interacting regulatory tools directed toward common climate objectives. It argues that the central legal question is not whether one instrument is intrinsically superior, but whether the ensemble is sufficiently effective, coherent, proportionate, administratively workable and distributively defensible. The European Union provides the most developed contemporary example. Its climate architecture combines binding economy-wide targets, two emissions-trading systems, national effort- sharing obligations, land-use and removals rules, renewable-energy and energy-efficiency legislation, a carbon border adjustment mechanism, climate governance duties and social compensation. The study analyses the benefits and risks of overlap, explains how judicial review increasingly scrutinises the adequacy and consistency of climate frameworks, and proposes legal design principles for managing instrument interactions under conditions of technological uncertainty, distributional conflict and long investment horizons.

PDF